Why are Neurodivergent Child Capable One Day And Overwhelmed The Next? A Neuroscientist Explains

Dr Paula Korczynska, a Neuroscience & Audiology researcher, an ADHD & Executive Function coach, and a neurodiversity advocate, who lives in Sydney, Australia, raises an interesting question that all parents of neurodivergent children often ask themselves: Why can a child complete a task excellently today, but tomorrow, he will have trouble with the very same task?

Based on her own experience working as a researcher in neuroscience, a coach and an educator in early childhood development, Dr Paula Korczynska explains why things like attention, emotional regulation, sleep, stress, and environment can affect the performance of your child. Moreover, she busts some myths about laziness and stubbornness in kids, suggesting looking behind the behaviour of a child.

In this interview with All About Inclusive, Dr Paula explains why your child’s ability doesn’t always correlate with his/her performance.

Also Read: An Ailing Wife, An Autistic Son And A Father’s Fight To Hold His Family Together.

Paula works primarily with adults with ADHD, supporting them with attention, organisation, task initiation, time management and emotional regulation. Her professional background also includes working as a university lecturer and serving as the principal of a post-secondary vocational school in Poland. In Australia, she worked in early childhood education and completed a Diploma in Early Childhood Education and Care. Readers can explore her research, articles and coaching work at http://www.dr-paula.net

Excerpts from the Interview:

Question) Many parents say, “My child did this perfectly yesterday, so why are they struggling with it today?” Why does this happen?

Answer) One of the most important things I try to explain is that being able to do something and being able to do it consistently are not the same thing. We often assume that once a child has learned a skill, they should be able to use it whenever they need to. But the brain does not work quite like that. A child’s ability to complete a task depends not only on what they know, but also on how much mental energy they have available, how they are feeling, what is happening around them, and how much effort the task requires at that particular moment.

Imagine a child who gets ready for school independently on Monday but cannot seem to manage the same routine on Tuesday. The child has not suddenly forgotten how to get dressed or pack a schoolbag. Perhaps they slept poorly, are worried about something at school, or are finding the morning environment particularly overwhelming. The task may look identical to the parent, but the demands on the child’s brain are not necessarily the same.

Also Read: Can Children Outgrow ADHD or Autism?

My research and coaching work focus primarily on adults with ADHD, but the difference between what someone is capable of doing and what they can actually manage in everyday situations is relevant across different stages of life. We tend to judge what someone can do based on what we have seen them achieve before. Once a person manages something successfully, we expect them to do it again, often without considering how much effort it took the first time. I would encourage parents to remember that yesterday’s success demonstrates that a skill is possible, but it does not guarantee that the child will have the same resources available to use it today.

Question) Is this inconsistency a sign that a child is being lazy, stubborn, or not trying hard enough?

Answer) Not necessarily, and I would be very careful about interpreting inconsistency as laziness or a lack of effort. When a child completes a task successfully one day but struggles with it the next, adults often assume that the child is choosing not to cooperate. After all, we have already seen that they can do it. But what we cannot see is how much effort the child is putting in, or what might be making the task more difficult today.

For children with ADHD, for example, starting a task, staying focused, remembering several instructions or moving from one activity to another can require considerable mental effort. A child may genuinely want to do what is being asked but struggle to organize their actions or get started. From the outside, this can look like avoidance, resistance or simply not listening.

Also Read: Teaching Neurodivergent Girls About Periods: Senior Doctor Shares Proven Tools and Tips

I think we also need to reconsider how we recognize effort. We tend to measure it by results. If a child finishes their homework, we assume they worked hard. If they spend twenty minutes staring at the page, we may assume they are not trying. Yet that child might be working extremely hard just to manage their frustration, resist distractions or figure out where to begin.

In my coaching practice, I work with adults with ADHD, and I often hear how much they struggled with being misunderstood when they were younger. Some describe growing up believing they were lazy or incapable because nobody recognized the effort they were making. Those experiences can stay with people for a very long time.

I also spent time working in early childhood education, where I observed how differently children respond to everyday expectations, even when they are similar in age and development. These experiences, although from different stages of life, have reinforced my interest in understanding the reasons behind behaviour rather than making assumptions about motivation.

Also Read: How Special Olympics Is Changing the Meaning of Inclusion for People with Intellectual Disabilities

Before deciding that a child is not trying, I would encourage parents to become curious about what is getting in the way. Sometimes the problem is not a lack of motivation, but the difficulty of turning that motivation into action.

Question ) What is happening in a child’s brain when they seem capable one day but overwhelmed the next?

Answer) To understand this, it helps to think about how the brain manages competing demands rather than imagining that a particular part of the brain simply stops working.

Everyday activities require several processes to work together. A child may need to hold instructions in mind, ignore distractions, manage frustration, decide what to do first and monitor what they are doing. These processes involve networks across the brain, including those supporting attention, working memory and self-regulation. In ADHD, the regulation of these functions can be less consistent.

Research has identified differences at the group level in brain systems involved in attention and cognitive control, including systems influenced by dopamine and noradrenaline. However, we cannot look at an individual child’s difficult morning and confidently attribute it to a particular chemical imbalance or brain network. What we can observe is that performance changes depending on the demands of the situation and the resources available to meet them.

For example, a child might manage a familiar task quite well when the environment is calm and an adult provides a little structure. The same task may become much harder when several people are talking, time is running out and the child is already upset about something that happened earlier. I often explain this in terms of mental workload. When more of a child’s attention is needed to manage distractions, emotions or uncertainty, less may be available for the task itself. The child has not necessarily lost an ability. They may simply be finding it harder to access and use that ability under the circumstances.

Also Read: When Should a Parent Stop Occupational Therapy? Dr. R.S.Bagga Answers the Most Common OT- related Questions

Question) Can things like poor sleep, stress, excitement, noise, or changes in routine affect a child’s ability to complete everyday tasks?

Answer) Absolutely. These factors can make a considerable difference, although their effects vary from child to child. Sleep is a good example. Even one night of poor sleep can make it harder to concentrate, regulate emotions and cope with frustration. For a child who already finds attention or self-regulation difficult, tiredness may make everyday demands feel much greater.

Stress is another factor. When a child is worried, upset or anticipating something difficult, part of their attention may be occupied by those feelings. Even positive excitement can make it difficult to settle into an ordinary task.

Noise is particularly interesting to me because of my research background in auditory processing. My doctoral research examined auditory function and everyday listening experiences in adults with ADHD. Although this research was not conducted with children, it has strengthened my interest in how complex listening environments may contribute to everyday difficulties. We often assume that if a child has normal hearing, they should be able to listen and follow instructions in any environment. But hearing sounds and managing complex listening situations are not the same thing. A child may hear perfectly well during a hearing test yet struggle to follow what a parent is saying when the television is on, siblings are talking and someone is moving around the kitchen. Listening in these conditions requires attention, filtering competing sounds and keeping spoken information in mind.

Changes in routine can also increase demands. A predictable morning allows a child to rely on familiar sequences. If something unexpected happens, they may suddenly need to rethink the plan, shift attention and manage disappointment or uncertainty.

Also Read: Waiting for Your Child to Speak? A Speech Therapist on the Signs Parents Should Not Miss

Rather than asking only whether a child knows how to complete a task, I would encourage parents to notice the conditions in which that task becomes easier or harder. Those patterns can tell us a great deal about what kind of support is useful.

Question) What are some common situations where parents might notice these ups and downs, such as getting ready for school, doing homework, or following instructions?

Answer) I think mornings are one of the clearest examples because they require so many different skills within a relatively short period. Getting ready for school sounds simple, but it involves remembering what needs to be done, estimating time, moving between activities, finding belongings and resisting distractions. A child might know every step perfectly well yet still struggle to put the steps together independently. Homework is another common situation. Parents sometimes wonder why a child can concentrate on a favourite activity for a long time but cannot sit down to complete a relatively short assignment. Attention is not simply a matter of deciding to concentrate. Interest, reward, task difficulty, fatigue and the surrounding environment can all influence how attention is regulated.

During my earlier work in early childhood education, I saw how much the structure of an activity and the surrounding environment could influence children’s participation. Some children responded well to verbal instructions, while others benefited from visual reminders, demonstrations or smaller steps. I learned that repeating the same instruction more loudly or more frequently was not necessarily the most effective approach.

I would encourage parents to look for patterns rather than isolated failures. Does the difficulty happen more often in the morning, after school, during noisy activities or when several instructions are given together? Understanding when and where a child struggle is often more useful than simply asking why they did not do what they were told.

Question) How can parents respond in a supportive way when a child suddenly struggles with something they usually manage well?

Answer) My first suggestion would be to resist the temptation to use yesterday’s performance as evidence against the child. Saying, “You managed this yesterday, so I know you can do it,” may sound encouraging to an adult. But for a child who is already struggling, it can feel like another reminder that they are failing to meet expectations. Instead, I would start by finding out what is making the task difficult today. That does not necessarily require a long conversation.

Also Read: Shivani and Vivaan: An Inspiring Autism Story From the UK

Sometimes a simple question such as “Which part is tricky right now?” is enough to identify the problem. I also encourage parents to think about reducing the demands of a task without immediately taking over. For example, if a child is overwhelmed by getting ready for school, an adult might help them identify the first step rather than repeating the entire list of things they need to do.

A child who cannot begin their homework might benefit from opening the book together, identifying the first question or setting up a quieter workspace. These small adjustments reduce some of the mental work required to get started. Support should also be flexible.

Question) What are some phrases parents should avoid saying, and what could they say instead to help their child feel understood and supported?

Answer) I would be cautious with phrases that question a child’s effort, intentions or character, particularly when the child is already frustrated. Comments such as “You’re just being lazy,” “You’re not even trying,” or “Why can’t you do something so simple?” can turn a practical difficulty into a judgement about who the child is. Even a seemingly harmless comment like “But you did it yesterday!” can leave a child feeling that their current struggle is somehow unacceptable.

I would suggest replacing these statements with questions that help the child understand what is happening and what might make the situation easier. Instead of “Why aren’t you listening?”, a parent might ask, “Did you catch what I said, or should I say it again one step at a time?” Instead of “Stop being difficult,” they might say, “I can see this isn’t going smoothly. What’s the hardest part?” And instead of “You know how to do this,” they could try, “You managed this before. Let’s work out what’s making it harder today.”

I also think it is valuable to acknowledge effort even when the outcome is not what we hoped for. A child who has struggled to begin a task may have been making a genuine effort long before an adult sees any progress.

Also Read: Faith Over Fear: Dubai-Mother Dr Nazima Saiyed on Raising Her Non-Speaking Autistic Son

Question) If there is one message you would like every parent of a neurodivergent child to remember, what would it be?

Answer) I would want parents to remember that inconsistency does not cancel out ability, and difficulty does not automatically mean a lack of effort. A child can be intelligent, capable, motivated and genuinely willing to cooperate, yet still struggle with tasks that appear simple to other people. Those struggles deserve to be understood, not dismissed simply because the child succeeded on another occasion.

One of the things I find particularly important in my work with adults with ADHD is how often people continue to carry negative messages from childhood. Some have spent years believing that they were lazy, unreliable or simply not good enough, even when they were working extraordinarily hard to meet expectations.

Although I now work primarily with adults, my earlier experience in early childhood education gave me the opportunity to observe children at an important stage of development. Looking at these experiences from both ends of the lifespan has made me particularly interested in how early interpretations of behaviour can shape the way people understand themselves later in life.

Parents have an opportunity to help children develop a different understanding of themselves. Instead of growing up asking, “What’s wrong with me?”, a child can gradually learn to ask, “What makes this difficult for me, and what helps?”. That is a much more useful question, both in childhood and later in life.

I would also remind parents that supporting a child does not mean removing every challenge or lowering expectations indefinitely. It means recognizing that children may need different pathways towards the same goals, and that independence develops through appropriate support, practice and understanding.

About the author

Nivedita

I am Nivedita, a journalist with nearly two decades of experience covering health, entertainment, fashion, and films. After working with media organizations such as IANS, HT, Network18, and Outlook, I created All About Inclusive—a platform focused on empathy, acceptance, and appreciation, as I strongly believe these voices make the world better.

All About Inclusive celebrates the inspiring journeys of individuals who have overcome challenges to succeed. Whether you are neurodivergent, a parent, a doctor, a therapist, or an advocate, this platform honours your story with sincerity, respect, and wholehearted recognition.

By Nivedita

Nivedita

I am Nivedita, a journalist with nearly two decades of experience covering health, entertainment, fashion, and films. After working with media organizations such as IANS, HT, Network18, and Outlook, I created All About Inclusive—a platform focused on empathy, acceptance, and appreciation, as I strongly believe these voices make the world better.

All About Inclusive celebrates the inspiring journeys of individuals who have overcome challenges to succeed. Whether you are neurodivergent, a parent, a doctor, a therapist, or an advocate, this platform honours your story with sincerity, respect, and wholehearted recognition.

Get in touch

All About Inclusive celebrates the inspiring journeys of individuals who have overcome challenges to succeed. Whether you are neurodivergent, a parent, a doctor, a therapist, or an advocate, this platform honours your story.